Friday, September 16, 2016

S.S. AUSTRAL SINKING SYDNEY HARBOUR, AUSTRALIA, 1882


 S.S.  AUSTRAL  
SINKING IN SYDNEY HARBOUR, AUSTRALIA, 1882.
Subsequent raising and refitting to sail on until 1903. 

Written from personal research by George W. Randall, co-founder in 1996 and former Vice-Chairman Kinloch Castle Friends' Association.
 * 
BACKGROUND  INTRODUCTION


>+<  >+<  >+< >+< >+<      >+<  >+<  >+< >+< >+<



PLEASE READ NOTES AT END OF THIS POST -

THANK YOU.
*
The 5,524 ton steamer Austral was not only the flag ship of the Orient Line
but the newest and finest vessel on the 
England to Australia route when she arrived in Sydney on her maiden voyage on 30 June 1882.

Less than five months later Austral was sitting on the bottom of the harbour in Sydney's Neutral Bay, off Circular Quay.

 11 November 2024 -
142 years since the sinking.
*
This article brings together in one place personal research, publicly available material and illustrations from dozens 
of sites on Google concerning the life 
history of the Orient Navigation Company’s Steam Ship Austral



A full list of sources is given at the end of this paper.
All are gratefully acknowledged!

********   ****************   ********

A QUICK SUMMARY OF THE 



********   ****************   ********
In September 1892, twenty-two year old George Bullough embarked
on a thirty-five month world tour.
On Sunday, 20 May 1893 he arrived in Sydney Australia 
on board the restored steamer Austral 
which had sunk eleven years previously while coaling 
in Sydney Harbour’s Neutral Bay with the loss of five lives. 

Bullough returned home in August 1895,
when he immediately set off on an eight month “supplementary cruise”
aboard his newly purchased steam yacht “Maria” which he renamed “Rhouma”.

S T O L E N
This original painting of SS Rhouma at Cowes Regatta in 1896 
signed and dated by maritime artist Charles Dixon  
was stolen from Kinloch Castle on 15 October 2023  -  
it has not been recovered.
 
******************************************************

YOU MAY ALSO BE INTERESTED IN ... ... ...

On 30 October 1894 Bullough arrived in Auckland the day SS Wairarapa hit rocks 
close to Miner's Head, Great Barrier Island, 
New Zealand, almost 128 years ago.

I have posted an article on this tragic event, the third worst in New Zealand maritime history. 
It can be viewed by clicking on -

S.S. WAIRARAPA  WRECKED MINER’S HEAD, GREAT BARRI...


******************************************************

    SS Austral was classed as 100A1 in Lloyd’s Register.   (The Illustrated Naval and Military Magazine.)
The ship sank at her mooring in Sydney Harbour on 11 November 1882.


(Photograph 23 from George Bullough's Photograph Album VII. Australia.)

While coaling in the early hours of 11 November 1882
Austral heeled over and sank off Kirribilli Point, Neutral Bay, Sydney.
****

****  ****  ****
Designed by naval architect J. W. Shepherd, Austral was built “under special licence
at the Fairfield, Govan, Shipyard of  John Elder & Co., Clydebank, Scotland,
as a passenger / cargo vessel for the Orient Steam Navigation Company, the managers of the line were Messrs. Anderson and Anderson.

In case of emergency “Austral carried ten boats; one large steam launch, four large 
life-boats, one small life-boat (fitted to patent davits for very rapid and safe lowering 
in case of ‘man overboard’), two very large cutters, a mail boat and a gig. 
Masts, sails, water-breakers, &c., are always kept in the boats, which are slung from the davits on patent detaching hooks.”

Austral had a double bottom divided into nineteen water-tight compartments with thirteen water-tight bulkheads in her hull. She was specially constructed to act as a cruiser and to carry guns in case of war, extra care was therefore taken in her design to ensure should such a need arise the vessel would be serviceable as such with minimal delay. 

To meet this need, principally the vessel’s strength, protection of vital parts from injury, buoyancy, extraction of water and firefighting capability, the Orient Company not only met but exceeded the requirements of the Admiralty for a war cruiser.

In order to give maximum protection to the engines the June 1882 edition of The Marine Engineer states “a bed of coals several feet deep (the coal bunkers) surrounded 
the engines, and beyond this it is to be so arranged that bales of compressed wool 
may be stowed as to provide armour for the whole hull of the ship.”



The diagram right illustrates the location of the coal bunkers which did not run side to side across the vessel but were individual compartments gained via chutes from port and starboard hatches immediately below the main deck.

The Australian trade was seasonal with October to February being the peak - 
winter in the northern hemisphere, summer in the southern. 
Orient line sailings to Australia were alternatively via the Suez Canal or Cape of Good Hope.
*
Launched on 21 December 1881 and following fitting out and sea trials, Austral departed the River Clyde at 5 pm. on 29 April 1882. 
“After a run of 42 hours and ten minutes at a speed of 16.10 knots,” 
the ship sailed up the River Thames into Albert Dock
 to be delivered to her owners, the Orient Line in London on 1 May. 
Austral’s maiden voyage departed London for Sydney, Australia, 
via Plymouth on 20 May 1882 
under Captain John Murdoch carrying 403 passengers, and cargo.


After calling at Naples, Austral’s route was through the Suez Canal, 
with re-coaling scheduled at Aden, (today Yemen), where delay occurred owing 
to an outbreak of cholera on shore. Austral departed Aden on 7 July direct
 to Melbourne averaging 345 miles a day. In reality the ship could make 
the voyage to Australia without the need to take on more fuel.

(Austral's coal bunkers held 2,500 tons equal to 40+ days steaming 
at 2½ tons per hour at 17 knots.)

Austral’s maiden sailing from Great Britain was via the Bay of Biscay, 
Mediterranean Sea, Suez Canal with re-coaling at Aden before crossing the 
Indian Ocean to Sydney via Melbourne.
The second crossing traversed the Atlantic Ocean to the Caribbean island of 
St. Vincent then back for re-coaling at Simon's Town, South Africa, 
prior to the southerly path across the Indian Ocean to Sydney via Melbourne.
*
Sydney Harbour (Port Phillip Bay) - Orient Line Guide 1888  (Google)

*
Crossing the Indian Ocean Austral encountered heavy seas and strong currents due to the south-west monsoon, finally arriving in Port Phillip Bay, Sydney on 30 June via Melbourne  and docking at Circular Quay.

SS Austral with coaling tender Woonona alongside.
After discharging the passengers and cargo, coaling commenced for the return 
journey, “this had barely started when the ship developed a moderate list.”
This was trimmed, but no one from Captain Murdoch down questioned 
why a vessel designed to carry 5,500 tons of cargo and coal should 
exhibit clear evidence of instability.

Built of mild steel, the vessel was 474 feet long, 48 feet wide with a depth of 37 feet.
Austral had five decks; a promenade deck capable of being used in all weathers; an upper deck of steel covered with three inches of teak; the main deck also steel with three inches of pitch-pine over; the lower deck of steel from the line of the engine and boiler room casing out to the ship's side and covered with three inches of pitch-pine; and the orlop deck of yellow pine 2½ inches thick.

Load line displacement was 9,500 tons. Engines were 3 cylinder compound inverted.

                          Full width Dining Saloon.
Austral had four boilers heated by six fires giving a steam pressure of 95-lbs, sq. inch.

“The (Admiralty) contract stipulated 5,800 indicated horse power but on the delivery run the engines developed 7,114 horse power and coal consumption was 1.3-lbs. per hour for every horse power indicated,” but the ship was empty of passengers and cargo and met no inclement conditions.
*
The single 22 foot diameter propeller was driven by a hollow shaft of compressed steel and comprised four blades of neutral manganese bronze, the boss being of cast steel. 
The pitch of the screw was 30 feet.

Third Class passenger saloon.
For the more technically minded, “the propelling machinery consisted of a compound inverted cylinder surface condensing engine, having one high pressure cylinder 63 inches in diameter and two low pressure cylinders each 86 inches in diameter with a stroke of five feet. Each cylinder was fitted with two equilibrium piston slide valves in lieu of the ordinary flat valve slide valve. 
Steam and hydraulic gear were provided for reversing and handling the engines when required. 
Two surface condensers and pumps were placed at the back of the engines, each low pressure engine being connected to its own condenser and air pump.”

Austral’s Chief engineer was John McDougall.
*
The interior was “to the highest standard (with) massive staircases of polished oak, 
rich decoration of white and gold and walnut paneling emblazoned with the coats 
of arms of England, other great nations and the British colonies.”
The owners “introduced several novelties for securing increased comfort 
and safety, including a hospital, well stocked library and a cabinet organ 
in the saloon where passengers reclined on velvet upholstered sofas, 
or sat in revolving chairs under a large 
domed ceiling above magnificent painted glass panels.”


A corner of the Dining Saloon.      (Illustrated London News)
Furnishings would be secured to the floor, dining chair seats would swivel on their legs.

*
The dining room was “said to be superior to those in the best Sydney hotels.”
Cabins for the time were well fitted, spacious and comfortable.
In an article on 21 March 1882 the Melbourne daily The Age wrote, 
“the first-class baths are of marble and the lavatory accommodation 
for all classes is unusually abundant,
 even the third-class passengers have a bathroom specially reserved for them.”


ABOVE:
Swan Ceiling Mount 
Obscure Globe.

(Electrical Times)

BELOW:
Swan Wall Mount 
Obscure Globe.


“At night dynamo-electric machines generate electricity to light up the whole ship. Arc lights give a power of 3,600, and the Swan 3,400, or a total of 7,000 candles. The current was provided by two Siemens alternating current machines each driven by a separate engine strong enough to drive both.” 

A gangway, four feet wide, ran right along
 Austral’s hull sides this 
permitted the staterooms 
to be constructed with windows
 instead of portholes and
   “the 
portholes to be opened even in rough weather without any
fear of water entering the cabin.”

(Quote and illustration: London News - Marine Engineer)

*
All the public rooms, pantries and passageways were lighted by 170 ceiling or wall mounted obscure globe Swan lamps. 
The engine room, decks and hatches by nine arc lamps.                     
The electrical equipment was fitted by Messrs. Siemen Brothers, Charlton, Kent, England. 
Previously oil lamps were  used. 
Austral provided its 550 passengers, (120 first class, 130 second class, 300 third class), with a level of comfort not previously available.

LEFT: Saloon passengers reclined on velvet upholstered sofas. RIGHT: Twin berth cabin.
 (Illustrated London News)

Full width Dining Saloon.
“The commissariat department is well attended to, and the most hypercritical passenger will have some difficulty finding any cause for complaint with fresh meat, fish,
 butter and milk from the refrigerating chamber served with iced wines, 
beer and mineral waters daily.”
(Picture and quote from: The Illustrated Naval and Military Magazine.)


*
Austral’s four masts and topsail yards were made of steel. 
The upper topsail yards were of wood and fitted with patent reefing gear and 
so constructed they could be lowered and stowed away along the sides of 
the deck when the ship was steaming against the wind.
The fore and main sails were square rigged, the mizzen and jigger having fore 
and aft sails, together Austral carried 28,000 square feet of canvas which was
 worked by steam winches.

Should steam failure occur the winches could be worked manually.

Oil painting of Austral under canvas by Thomas Goldsworth Dutton. 

Austral was principally powered by steam, her 2,500 ton coal bunkers being 
filled through special coaling ports running amidships just below the main deck, 
eight on the starboard side, seven on the port. 
The coaling hatches measured 39 by 30 inches and when the ship was empty 
of cargo were 54 inches above the waterline.
Coal consumption was estimated at 2½ tons per hour at average trial speed 17½ knots.

*
The 15 coaling hatches were amidships, eight starboard, seven to port.
The refrigeration chamber was located immediately above the propeller shaft.
*
Ahead of her time in many respects, the ship had a double bottom, 
an inner skin and was divided into nineteen water-tight bulkheads, 
with ten rising to the main deck; above which were
seven fireproof compartments. Should fire break out “the ship is fitted with 
flooding-pipes from which large quantities of water or steam can be forced” 
in all parts of the vessel.


Should flooding occur the pumps could handle 11,000 gallons a minute.
Austral was also fitted with a 13,283 cubic foot freezer room, 
approximately 38 x 35 x 10 feet.    The “refrigeration apparatus (was) of a new plan 
and of such dimensions that 17,000 sheep (carcasses) could be carried each voyage.” The equipment was the invention of  forty-two year old 
Archibald Douglas Bryce-Douglas, head of the engineering department 
of the ship’s builders, John Elder, & Co. “Most refrigeration hitherto used to 
add moisture to the air in the process of cooling,” 
Mr. Bryce-Douglas’s invention “not only extracts the heat, 
but expels the air drier than when it receives it.” “Air of an ordinary summer temperature can quickly be reduced to 30 degrees below zero.” 
During the delivery run “a temperature of ten degrees below zero was maintained in the empty chamber ...  ... which is located just above the propeller shaft.”

Detail from George Bullough's Photograph from Album VII. 

On the evening of 3 November, 1882, after a stormy and far from trouble  
free second crossing lasting fifty-four days, Austral docked at Circular Quay, 
Sydney. With her passengers ashore and most of her cargo unloaded, re-coaling commenced with a collier belonging to the Bulli Coal Company, pulling 
along Austral’s starboard side and secured with hawsers.
(Austral’s  port was alongside Circular Quay therefore only the  starboard hatches 
were accessible. See picture below.)


(State Library of New South Wales)

Arriving Sydney on Friday 3 November 1882 Austral docked port side to Circular Quay
leaving only the starboard hatches accessible for re-coaling.
After developing a slight list coaling stopped. This was eventually trimmed and a week later the ship was moved to the Orient Line’s mooring off Kirribilli Point.
In the interim William Cruikshank, Government Marine Surveyor, 
inspected the troublesome engines and finding a flaw in the drive shaft 
recommended it be removed for repair at workshops on nearby Cockatoo Island.

NOTE: The collier’s vertical mast can be seen to the left of Austral’s foremast 
which has a definite lean to starboard.
*
Inside the ship’s bunkers, with all coal hatches open to aid ventilation, 
eighteen trimmers laboured to evenly distribute the coal as it was loaded. 
It was not only dirty but extremely dangerous work.

All morning they swetted. When, with 230 tons loaded, Austral suddenly gave a 
marked list to starboard, coaling stopped. 
Foreman William Hadden sent for his supervisor, Carl Carlson, 
who found the starboard coaling ports barely eighteen inches above the waterline.
                                                                                
Provisioning barge along port side Austral.

* >< * >< * >< * >< * >< * >< * >< * >< * >< * >< * >< * >< * >< * >< * >< *



* >< * >< * >< * >< * >< * >< * >< * >< * >< * >< * >< * >< * >< * >< * >< *

Captain Murdoch was consulted but refused a request by Carlson to carry coals 
across the deck to the port side in a bid to right the ship. 
It took the crew of Woonona five hours to put Austral back on an even keel before 
she could be moved. Warning number two had come and gone with scant attention shown by those whose job it was to ensure the safety of the ship and its crew.
Coaling was stopped until Friday 10 November when Austral was moved from 
Circular Quay to the Orient Line’s mooring off Kirribilli Point, Neutral Bay,
 a distance of about one mile.

Meanwhile, Chief Government Marine Surveyor, William Douglass Cruikshank inspected the troublesome engines. During the outward voyage from England 
the high pressure valve gear had twice broken down necessitating disconnection, 
the ship forced to proceed under sail assisted by
her two low pressure engines. Mr. Cruikshank found “several minor faults with (Austral’s) workings and a major flaw in the propeller shaft.”
(A marine inspection was routine on all ships prior to maritime authorities issuing 
the necessary certificates enabling them to put to sea.)
At the subsequent Inquest, Mr. Cruikshank deposed he had been 
“called upon to examine the machinery of the Austral on several occasions 
since she arrived this time. Last Wednesday, (8 November) I suggested 
that a length of the shafting should be removed from the tunnel.

It was the length next to the engine. I had observed a flaw, hence my recommendation.
The length weighed 10 or 12 tons. I did not consider removal of that weight from the bottom of the ship would have affected her stability to the slightest degree. 
When I examined the machinery I did not examine the valves and sea cocks. 
When I saw the vessel there was nothing in the defects of the machinery
 which rendered her un-seaworthy.”

The shaft, technically called a “built shaft”, was made of “best steel”.

Mr. Cruikshank recommended it removed for repair to nearby machine shops
on Cockatoo Island, about two miles upstream.

Promenade Deck SS Austral looking aft.     
(The Illustrated Naval and Military 
Magazine.)
*

        With canvas unfurled Austral sailed along at 7 knots.

This delay was especially worrying as smallpox had broken out at Cape Town, 
twenty-five miles to the north.  After three days, with repairs completed, Austral commenced the last leg of her journey to Australia. 
She soon steamed into “strong westerly gales and huge seas” which for three days battered the vessel. One thousand miles out from the Cape of Good Hope, 
with the weather moderated, all seemed “in capital order” until a problem 
with the high-pressure piston again required disconnection.

During the eighteen hours for repair the canvas was unfurled and Austral 
sailed along at seven knots aided by her two low-pressure engines, 
arriving Melbourne on Wednesday, 1 November. 
Despite assurances by the Pilot that the health risk encountered at Simon's Town 
did not require medical examination, immigration officials insisted all on board 
had to pass through the quarantine station. Three days later Austral finally
 berthed at Circular Quay, Sydney, at the end of her second voyage.

At 10 pm. on Friday, 10 November, with fine, clear weather, no wind and the 
sea dead calm, coaling recommenced. In Australs bunkers the eighteen trimmers laboured to evenly distribute the coal as it came down the chutes, 
all starboard hatches were open to aid ventilation. After an hour, with thirty tons loaded, the slight list, resulting from the earlier coaling, had been corrected.
The open ports, Foreman Hadden noted, were four feet above the waterline.

The Bulli Coal Companys collier Woonona was contracted to coal Austral 
while she was berthed at Circular Quay. 

Despite the earlier listing occurrence, the master of the collier, Captain Morwick, received no instruction to move his vessel to the other side of Austral
Coaling continued at 25 to 30 tons an hour and by 2.30 am. the aft reserve bunkers were full and loading moved to the mid bunker chutes.    
Half-an-hour later Foreman Hadden again checked the height of the coaling 
ports and found them to be “approximately two feet” above the waterline.
He also noted “a slight list of the vessel to starboard ... not sufficient to excite apprehension of danger,” he recalled at the subsequent inquiry.

Coaling continued.

The 15 coaling hatches were amidships, eight starboard, seven to port.

*
3.50 am. Saturday, 11 November, 1882. 
As first light heralded the dawn of a new day, the sound of rushing water drowned 
out all other noise. Cries of “shes sinking!” were heard as panic broke out amongst
 the trimmers as water poured in through the loading hatches.
Lamp trimmer William Lowman, who had been assigned night watchman, 
went down to the saloon shouting “all hands on deck!” to rouse the sleeping crew, 
who because of the summer heat had opened many of the portholes for air.


As Austral’s list increased it threatened to crush the collier tied alongside.

“Cut the ropes” cried Captain Morwick as Woonona’s engine was started and she slowly pulled away from the sinking ship suffering no more than a broken mast.

(Illustrated Sydney News)




Austral's fore main deck was eighteen inches below the water at low tide. 
The after part of the vessel was about ten feet under water 
inclined to starboard at 13 degrees.

><  *   >< ><  *   ><><  *   ><
Forty minutes later, at 4.30am., with 1,500 tons of coal and 200 tons of iron on board, 
but short of several hundred tons of water ballast
Austral sank stern first in fifty-two feet of water with a list to starboard of 
thirteen degrees. No part of her hull was visible only the upper chart house on
the port side of the bridge, the four masts and two funnels. 
As it was less than eleven months since Austral was launched and only her second sailing, her owners had the ship insured for her actual cost £200,000.*

(* Figure quoted at the subsequent official London Inquiry. 
Some newspapers report £250,000 as to Austral’s actual cost.)




Austral sank with a 13° list to starboard on a rising seabed of mud. View looking forward.
Note the water-tight bulkhead as integral part of the cofferdam.
(From: The Engineer, Volume 35, Page 368 - 20 April 1883)
*
*
The collier Woonona pulls away safely
suffering only a broken mast.
 (Scientific American)
Divers found the bodies of five crew members, three Arab coal trimmers - 
Ali Hassin aged twenty; 
Saleh and Falim Mahomet 
aged 23 and 25; 
purser John James Perkins aged 29 and refrigeration engineer, Thomas Alexander, 
aged twenty-two. 

The Illustrated Sydney News reported 
all were interred at Haslam’s Creek Cemetery.

A Coroner’s Inquiry convened on Monday, 13 November into the deaths of the five men. Over six days the jury heard evidence from all members of Austral’s crew and employees of the Bulli Coal Company. Possible causes of the accident included the removal of the ten ton drive shaft, but the main focus was on the amount of ballast water in the tanks directly above the keel. 
On the night in question they contained only 180 tons, 22% of their 800 ton capacity.
Had this altered the ship's equilibrium? Was the foreman of the collier guilty for not moving his vessel to the other side when the list became evident?
+

Before the jury retired to consider their verdict the Coroner, Mr. J. Shiell, J.P.
explained: “a simple error of judgement would not render the captain or any of his officers liable to a charge of manslaughter. However if the jury felt any person was guilty of criminal negligence and this had caused the drowning of the five men, that person or persons would be guilty of manslaughter.”

The jury deliberated for five hours before returning, the foreman announcing there was no chance of a unanimous verdict. Would Mr. Justice Shiell accept a majority verdict? “No” was the reply.
After a further ninety minutes deliberation the jury returned saying they had agreed 
on a verdict and found “the men drowned in the steamer Austral (as a result of) gross negligence of Captain John Murdoch and officers of the ship.”

The Coroner replied, “Then you find the captain and his officers ... guilty of manslaughter?” Several jurors immediately replied: “No, we do not mean that at all!” The Coroner said in that case they had not agreed on a verdict. He reminded them that finding any of the officers guilty of gross negligence then that constituted manslaughter.

The jury retired again and four hours later returned naming the captain, chief officer, chief engineer and carpenter as “committing a gross error of judgement.” 
The wording, substituting “judgement” for “negligence” ensured all those named 
were not guilty of manslaughter.
Captain Murdoch had his Master’s Certificate suspended.


Bow section during salvage work. 

With the Coroner’s Inquest concluded Captain Murdoch was petitioned to face a 
Court of Marine Inquiry on 4 December in Sydney. With five days to the hearing 
a letter from the Board of Trade in London was received 
“requesting his Excellency the Governor (of New South Wales  - 
Lord Augustus William Frederick Spencer Loftus), to forgo the Inquiry.”
Justification for this unprecedented move being “the Inquiry should take place 
in England where plans of the ship and evidence of certain scientific witnesses 
could be taken into account.”

Despite the New South Wales’ Marine Board’s right to hold a hearing into the 
sinking the Inquiry was cancelled.
Meanwhile local newspapers, particularly the Sydney Morning Herald, 
disagreed. Citing the two previous occasions the vessel had clearly shown signs 
of instability as evidence the captain and officers on board Austral did not 
understand the conditions that affected their vessel. 
That when deep in the water with cargo there was less need for ballast; 
when the cargo was removed the need to increase ballast was essential to 
maintain stability. The paper particularly highlighted that during the ship’s 
maiden voyage Austral had developed a list when only 120 tons of coal had been 
loaded for her return to England, and this in a 5,500 ton vessel!

The Board of Trade in London held a formal investigation “into the 
circumstances attending the foundering of the steamship Austral in Neutral Bay, Sydney Harbour, on 11 November 1882, whereby five lives were lost" at Sessions House, Westminster, on 24 to 28 September and
1 to 3 and 6 October 1883, chaired by the Wreck Commissioner, H. C. Rothery.


The comprehensive and critical Report was published on 6 October 1883.
The Court concluded “that the ship foundered due to coaling having been continued 
so long on the starboard side as to give the vessel a list sufficient to put the after port holes on that side under water, upon which the vessel filled and went down; 
and that John Murdoch, the master,
and Godfrey Turner Richards, the chief officer, are to blame for the casualty,
but under (all) the circumstances it will not deal with their certificates.”

The full Board of Trade Wreck Report for Austral - 1883 can be found on Google:



The Report is comprehensive and well worth reading.
There is conjecture about the lack of stability testing prior to delivery and the 
amount of water in the 800 ton ballast tanks at the time of the sinking
and why they were not full during re-coaling when the ship was “light”.

The ballast tanks were under the direct control of  Captain Murdoch, Austral’s master.
*
There were no fatalities during the raising of Austral although diver George Murray
was very lucky to be resuscitated after a screw in the pump
to his airline became disconnected.
 

Austral lay on a sloping muddy sea bed with a high risk of sinking ever deeper 
and reaching a point beyond which raising her would be impossible. 
With no time to lose the Orient Steam Navigation Company appointed engineers Stanford and Eldridge to proceed to Sydney to ascertain the best way to raise 
their flagship liner.
Mr. George Eldridge, M.I.N.A., as the Orient Line's naval architect oversaw the whole plan in conjunction with Mr. G. Skelton Yuill, A.I.C.E., the Company’s resident Sydney manager at their 39 Pitt Street office, and Mr. John Standfield, M.Inst.C.E., for raising the ship.
On Saturday, 30 December 1882 Captain Chisholm, chief surveyor of the Surveying Department of Lloyd’s Association arrived in Sydney to represent the underwriters of the ship “and on their behalf, if necessary, to advise with regard to the plan to be adopted in raising her.

Meanwhile sixteen divers had been busy working their way through the ship's dark interior salvaging movable and valuable articles from saloons and cabins. It was slow, dangerous work, their gear “weighed 150-lbs. when wet”, their air supply  pumped through 180 feet of pipe.

Local boat owners were quick to take advantage of interest the sinking generated. 
Soon regular excursions were leaving Circular Quay to give the paying public 
a closer look at the stricken vessel and efforts being undertaken to bring 
her back to the surface.  

For "6d. Return" one entrepreneur would transfer sightseers to the steamer Alathea moored close to Austral for a longer view of the salvage 
work picking them up later.


RAISING OF THE AUSTRAL
The new steamers MASCOTTE and ELAINE leave No. 3 Jetty
every fifteen minutes, from 6 to 6 during the day. No. 3 Jetty.
No. 3 Jetty.          W. J. Harmer, Manager.
H.W.B.S.F. Company.
*
THE GREATEST NAUTICAL EVENT THE
WORLD HAS EVER SEEN
THE RAISING OF THE AUSTRAL
Steamers will leave No. 3 Jetty through the day, and go round the Austral.
N.B. - Note No. 3 Jetty.                                         No. 3 Jetty
*
RAISING THE AUSTRAL - Steamers plying
from No. 4 Jetty every 15 minutes ONLY are allowed to
transship passengers on board S. ALATHEA, especially moored off
Austral for that purpose; return 6d.   No. 4 Jetty only.


Another boatload of sightseers circle the stricken liner.
The white funneled vessel moored in the background is most likely the steamer 
Alathea to which passengers could be transferred for a longer look at the recovery 
work and be picked up later.
*
The initial method chosen to raise the ship was for divers to seal all open hatchways and ports, and pump the water out. Due to an “inadequacy of skilled divers” this proved impracticable so a heavily reinforced 410 foot long 30 foot deep coffer dam was constructed in weighted 16 foot sections and lowered in for assembly and “secured to the hull by bolts passed through scuttle lights and through oak toggles on the inside, and similarly to other toggles or stringers passing behind the stanchions on the promenade deck” by the divers. Made of four inch thick kauri pine planks strongly fitted together, the dam formed an encasing wall 10 inches thick rising out of the water well above deck level and heavily braced. It was made watertight by a covering of 26,000 square feet of canvas. 
“The coffer dam itself was divided by a watertight bulkhead as the division gave great facilities in trimming the vessel as she rose.”


The purpose of the coffer dam was to seal the ship, it did not encase the whole submerged vessel as in a floating dock.

It extended over all port holes and loading doors - 
410 feet of the vessels 470 foot length, and well above promenade deck height where it was secured with heavy timber bracing and steel hawsers.
Working day and night in shifts of six or eight hours, the divers were paid an average 
£1 for a six hour shift and thirty shillings (£1.50) for nine hours.
Labourers received one pound a week.
It took sixteen divers and eighty-five men sixteen weeks 
before the coffer dam was completed and tested.
On 26 February, 1883, everything was ready to remove over three million gallons of water weighing more than 11,500 tons.



Powerful centrifugal pumps were fixed to remove water in the fore and aft holds.
Looking aft, with some of the water removed the cofferdam can be seen extending more clearly above the previously totally submerged deck.

*

The ship sank in 52 feet of water. The cofferdam was constructed to withstand the lateral pressure 
of 9-lbs. per square inch (almost 1,300-lbs. per square foot) the water outside 
as the water in the vessel was pumped out.

On Tuesday, 13 March 1883, 122 days after she sank and barely two weeks since pumping began, Austral rose from the sea bed of Neutral Bay. With most of the water pumped out it was now possible to inspect the interior of the ship. The Sydney Morning Herald reported:

“The first apartment entered from the promenade deck was the drawing room. The walls, formerly of enamel and gold, the domed ceiling and windows ornamented with graceful scroll work, the furniture cushioned with pale blue velvet, the floor covered with thick Indian carpets and windows curtained with fabric of white silk and gold thread, were now black and stained, the windows broken, the curtains torn down and the velvet furniture and costly carpets rotted to ruin. Passing down the massive staircase into the dining saloon, built to accommodate 120 diners, the same destruction was witnessed on a larger scale. Formerly the ceilings of this magnificent room was decorated with white and gold, the end walls ornamented with carved and emblazoned coats of arms of European nations and British Colonies, the revolving chairs, cushioned with ruby velvet and the saloon lighted by patent glass panels on each side, now the decorations are obliterated, the velvet completely rotted and stripped off the chairs, the coats of arms partly destroyed, the windows smashed and the handsome veneering so saturated it strips off like paper. In the state rooms the same process of destruction, everything not plain and solid, books wardrobes, settees, spring mattresses, electric lamps, everything, all hopelessly ruined.”

Massive timber bracing was required to withstand the 1,300-lbs. per square foot pressure on the hull as the water was pumped out of the ship.
*
As more water was pumped out it became possible to see clearly the damage below deck.
“The scene of destruction is impossible to convey”, wrote a reporter in The Sydney Mail, “the passages, cabins and floors are covered in inches of black, slimy mud. The walls and ceilings blackened, saturated with salt water and covered in marine growth. The stench of the bilge water and the worst experience of all going through the storerooms with the decayed and stinking supplies of flour, meat, tea, &c., which have been soaking there for four months. Two of the men sent to clear the storeroom were completely overpowered with fits of vomiting.”
*
Water had initially poured in through the coaling hatches, then through the open portholes, but once the deck was below sea level an appalling volume of water surged down stairways and ventilator shafts, tearing doors off their hinges, smashing walls, furniture, everything in its path; a massive tsunami sweeping everything in its path in the confines of the ship.
Whilst the open portholes had allowed water in they now provided a way out for crew members suddenly awakened from their slumbers.

*

Workshops Cockatoo Island.
Once free of the seabed Austral was towed to shallower water and beached at the top of a flood tide. The remaining water was pumped out, and, as the tide receded, the coffer dam could be removed. Now freely floating the vessel was trimmed preparatory to being taken into the 643 foot long Fitzroy Dry Dock on Cockatoo Island, about two miles upstream.
"Unfortunately, a series of exceptionally low tides thwarted to slipping of the vessel and it became necessary to dock the ship each night 
as it was too risky on account of the inside dimensions of the dry dock."  
However, better news came when the engine room was examined.

It was feared the engines and associated machinery would have been totally destroyed by the action of the sea water but this proved not to be the case. Following stripping down, a good clean and overhaul, most key parts were returned to working order.

Within twelve weeks of entering dry dock newspapers reported Austral was cleaned 
and repaired sufficiently to be returned for refitting to her builders 
at the Clydebank Shipyard of John Elder & Co.
But first, on 28 May 1883, amid much fanfare a group of distinguished guests and those associated 
with the vessels reconditioning were invited for a trial run to test the engines and handling 
in preparation for departure to Scotland.

At 11.45am the steamer Prince of Wales transferred 250 guests from Circular Quay 
to the waiting Austral. Forty-five minutes later the tug Prince Alfred turned Austral’s
prow towards the open sea and she was underway. 
Out of the harbour Austral turned right and set off down the coast gradually building up speed 
while her guests dined and toasted the “success of the Orient Company.” 
Captain Slader took his charge to almost 17 knots, informing journalists
 he was going to sail her home to Great Britain via Cape Horn. 
Abreast of Port Hacking Austral turned and made her way back to harbour, 
ending what was described “as a pleasant afternoon.”

  
The Maitland Mercury - 2 June 1883.


Melbourne Argus - 29 May 1883.

Austral was scheduled to leave Sydney under her own power on 5 June 1883 via Cape Horn for Scotland under the command of Captain Henry Yorke Slader, R.N.R., she carried no passengers or cargo. Austral arrived back in London on 3 August, fifty-nine days later.
Three days later she sailed to her original builders at Glasgow and berthed into Queen's Dock “to be refitted and redecorated in the same manner as before her accident.”
At the same time a series of stability tests were carried out. This involved moving a 10-ton weight to various positions around the promenade deck and measuring the incline of the hull.
At the London Inquiry her designer, Mr. J. Shepherd, told the court he had neglected to carry out any such test previously stating the builders were being pressed to deliver the vessel and he “did not think, knowing the style of the ship that it was necessary to do so,” adding, “he had designed the Orient (sister ship to Austral) and she was supposed to be the finest ship in the world. 
Austral was intended to be an improvement having two feet more beam.”


While anchored in the River Clyde Austral was rammed by the S.S. Cassia.

Incident Report from: Transactions of the Institution of Naval Architects Volume XXVII:


*

SS Orient sister ship to SS Austral.
Built 1879 by John Elder & Co., Orient was the Orient Steam Navigation 
Company's first ship.
Single screw, rigged for sail, speed 15 knots. 5,386 tons gross. 460 feet in length 
with a 46.3 foot beam and depth of 35 feet. Designed to carry 550 passengers. 
When registered Orient was the largest ship in the world apart from 
Brunel's 19,000 ton Great Eastern.
Orient was scrapped in 1910 after thirty-one years’ service.

(Photograph 22 from George Bullough's Photograph Album VII. Australia.)

*
The stability tests found that it was the deserted aft coaling ports that began 
to fill first.
The ship had in fact been taking water for a considerable time before it was 
noticed by the men coaling the forward ports. The examiners also found that if 
the whole of the 120 tons of coal had been loaded in pocket bunkers situated 
within 7 feet of the side of the vessel this would explain how the accident happened. 
They added “these valuable vessels should not be sent to sea till all the curves
 of stability had been drawn, and measures taken to ascertain what cargoes 
they were capable of carrying under varying conditions.” Despite this, the tests found Austral “was under almost every conceivable condition a very
 stable vessel.”

On 6 October the investigating Court handed down its decision, stating the ship’s sinking was caused be a series of small mistakes. 

“It was a mistake by the owners sending the ship to sea 
without calculating her stability, and supplying the 
captain with the information. 

It was a mistake to send her 
to sea with only four certified officers. 
(The court recommended six.) 

It was a mistake of the captain not to have taken warning 
from the previous lists, and to have turned in without 
satisfying himself that the chief officer was vigilant 
and attentive to his duties. 

It was a mistake of the chief officer to leave
 the ship in charge of a watchman and turn in himself.”

Despite this
the court did not cancel or suspend either man’s ticket.

The total cost of raising, cleaning and repairing the vessel, put at £50,000,  was defrayed by the underwriters.

   >< + >< + >< +>< + >< + >< +>< + >< + >< +>< + >< + >< + ><
            
In April 1884,  reconditioned to her former glory, Austral was subjected 
to a series of sea trials before being chartered by the Anchor Steamship Company 
for two voyages to New York from Liverpool prior to returning to her 
Orient Line Australia route.

Returned to her owners, the Orient Line, Austral left London  
on 21 November 1884 with 657 passengers bound for Sydney;
 forty-two days later, 2 January 1885 
she entered Sydney harbour. Only two of Austral's original crew, 
chief engineer John McDougall 
and second officer Mr. O. Marshall, served on-board.

(La Trobe Picture Collection - State Library of Victoria.)
Fancy dress on board Austral.
*
Deck games on refurbished Austral.
*
The press reported “the voyage throughout was rendered most enjoyable, 
concerts and other entertainment, including a fancy dress being given. 
The latter proved a great success all the ladies taking part and the handsome sum of 
120 pounds being realised for the different marine charities.”
Sadly during the voyage three passengers died ... ...

Austral at her mooring off Gravesend.  -  Original watercolour by Frank Baden-Powell 1883.

Because of her unfortunate record maritime superstition might have concluded  
Austral was an unlucky ship, this was not the case. 
Apart from a brief spell requisitioned as a troopship during the Boer War Austral 
continued in service as a passenger /cargo liner for a further twenty years becoming 
a familiar and popular sight in Sydney Harbour.

On 5 January 1903 the pride of the Orient Line arrived in Sydney on her fifty-second voyage.
Twelve days later she departed Circular Quay for the last time.
In May 1903 Austral left London for the Italian port of Genoa to be broken up.

The Marine Engineer reported on 1 June 1903 “the vessel was sold by her owners 
for a sum amounting to between £13,000 and £14,000.”

The Sydney Illustrated News commented:
“The sinking of the magnificent Orient steamer Austral is an occurrence almost without precedence in the annals of Maritime history.”

*
PLAN OF AUSTRAL FROM ORIENT LINE GUIDE 1888.
Digitised from Google





*






















Oil painting of Austral by Thomas Goldsworth Dutton (c.1818-1891)
Dutton is recognised as the finest nineteenth century lithographer to record shipping and shipping scenes, he is also a noted water-colourist and oil painter.


 Watercolour of Austral by William Lionel Wyllie - 1882
NATIONAL MARITIME MUSEUM GREENWICH


*
This article brings together in one place publicly available material and 
illustrations from dozens of sites by searching key words on Google.

The text is the result of on-going research by the author stimulated by 
the single photograph of SS Austral in the library at Kinloch Castle, Scotland, 
collected by George Bullough,
(later Sir George, Baronet), during his world travels in the late 19th century.
The twenty volumes of over six hundred pictures record events, places and people
from almost every continent, and all have a story to tell.

The raising of the passenger / cargo liner SS Austral in March 1883 from the
 seabed of Sydney harbour, the ship returning half way round the world 
via Cape Horn under her own power to her builders in Scotland for complete restoration, her return to service for another twenty years represents 
an incredible piece of Victorian engineering doggedness and human ingenuity.

             
             Watercolour SS Austral by William Lionel Wyllie [1851-1931] 
*

Painting of Austral by unknown artist.

(From: Modern Shipbuilding and the Men Engaged In It by David Pollock -Published 1884) 

<<  >>  <<  >>  <<  >>  *  <<  >>  <<  >>  <<  >>

















References:

Scientific American Supplement - February 1883, June 1883
Money Market Review - April 1884
Illustrated Sydney News - 1883
Illustrated London News - 1882
The Illustrated Australian News - March 1883
The Marine Engineer – Jan. 1882, June 1882, Nov. 1882, Dec. 1882, May 1883, June 1903.
The Sydney Morning Herald January, March and April 1883
The Engineer - April  and October 1883
The Sydney Mail - November 1882 and February 1883
Minutes of Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers – Raising the S.S. Austral 1883
United Kingdom Wreck Report for Austral Published 1883
The Melbourne Age November - 1882
Melbourne Argus - May 1883
The Mercury (Tasmania) - July 1882
The Daily Telegraph - March 1883
Remembering the Classic Liners of Yesteryear – www.ssmaritime.com
Grey River Argus - 1883
Timaru Herald(New Zealand) - November 1882
Proceedings of the United States Naval Institute - Volume IX 1883
The Bendigo Advertiser - November 1882
The Granville Guardian - August 2010
Electrical Times Volume 1 - 1891
Orient Line Guide 1888 (Google)
The Maitland Mercury and Hunter River Advertiser June - 1883
New Zealand Press (Issue 5353) - 1882
Taranaki Herald (New Zealand) - November 1882
The Inangahua Times - issue 1202, 1203 - December 1882
New Zealand Herald  - November 1882, February 1883
Australian Government Archives
The Bendigo Advertiser
The Maitland Mercury and Hunter River Advertiser June - 1883
State Library of New South Wales 
George W. Randall Research Archive 1992-2017
The Wreck Report for SS Austral, 1883 - Port Cities Southampton
The Press (New Zealand) - November 1882
Timaru Herald (New Zealand) November 1882
National Maritime Museum, Greenwich, London. (Watercolour)
The Illustrated Naval and Military Magazine - Volume III 1885
Transactions of the Institution of Naval Architects - Volume XXVI 1885
 Transactions of the Institution of Naval Architects - Volume XXVII 1886
The British Merchant Service Journal Volume IV - 1882
  Photo SS Austral Allan C. Green - State Library of Victoria
Ship of the Age - Austral - pages 46 - 59
Chris Frame Official -  SS Austral Sinking 
Modern Shipbuilding and the Men Engaged In It (David Pollock) - Published 1884
La Trobe Picture Collection - State Library of Victoria
Raising the SS Austral - Paper 1939 by John Standfield, M. Inst. C.E.


All sources, without which this article 

would not have been possible, 

are hereby gratefully acknowledged.

*




Text Copyright

GEORGE W. RANDALL RESEARCH AND PHOTOGRAPHIC ARCHIVE



KINLOCH CASTLE
AND ITS UNIQUE COLLECTION
OF CONTENTS ARE AT GREAT RISK 
OF BEING LOST FOREVER -



















                           Peggy’s Creations

https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=61551067101475




REVIEWED 31 OCTOBER 2024